Yanomamo tribe essay

I have compiled a historical outline of the Yanomamo tribe and some of their religion and culture, ranging from marital status to the type of food they eat. I have chosen this tribe because according to many anthropologists the Yanomamo are perhaps the last culture to have come in contact with the modern world. The Yanomamo people of Central Brazil are one of the oldest examples of the classic pre-Columbian forest footmen. The Yanomamo live in almost complete seclusion in the Amazon rain forests of South America.

Yanomamo tribe essay

Rapid and unforeseeable events have set the tone for the controversy. The study of these Amazonian Indians, who live in regions of the Venezuela and Brazil border, has turned in western exploitation.

Accusations about of unethical anthropologist are abundant, but little facts about such accusations are evident. The grand attention that these events have attained has turned into a focus on larger issues in anthropological practices. Most of the controversy stems from the publications about the Yanomamo tribe by anthropologist Napoleon Chagnon.

His volume Yanomamo: The Fierce People made the tribe famous due to good writing and extensive interaction with one of the most isolated people on the planet. But ultimately, the way that he portrayed them—violent and fierce—is what attracted wide audiences.

Much of his books and his video productions are centralized around the theme that the Yanomamo have an immutable trait of violence.

A Revised Sample Essay On The Topic Of The Yanomami Tribe

According to Chagnon, he collected data, interacted with opposing Yanomamo villages, and received testimony to arrive to his findings.

His researched was very lucrative; his book sold more than 4 million copies, which is well beyond the average of other ethnographies. He not only gained financial benefits, he began to be praised and attacked by people around the globe. People accused Chagnon of exaggerating the fact that violence is a part of their culture.

Popular Topics

For instance, French anthropologist Jacques Lizot, who lived with the Yanomamo for more than twenty years, said that violence is periodic; it does not govern their social life for long periods of time.

It is worth noting that Lizot was accused of homosexual acts with young Yanomamo and distributing guns. Others, like Kenneth Good, accused Chagnon of sensationalizing violence, which he elaborated in his book, New Yorkers: The Mugging and Murdering People.

Yanomamo tribe essay

He explains that just because violence occurs within the Yanomamo, does not mean they should all be generalized as violent. Good also received backlash for his research because he married a young Yanomamo girl, whom he now has three children with. Another compelling argument came from the studies of Brian Ferguson.

He states that there is a spike in violence during contact with Westerners. As it relates to Chagnon, because he brought western manufactured goods, such as steel and iron tools, he disrupted trading relationships, which lead to inter-village violence for the unequal access of those scarce and desired tools.

Among all the accusers, journalist Patrick Tierney gave the controversy the most attention. Published inthe book accuses Chagnon of misrepresenting the Yanomamo as fierce people, being responsible for warfare by interrupting trading relationships, staging film scenes, fabricating data, giving unsupported claims of being the first to contact with the Yanomamo, violating Venezuelan law, and overall unethical practices.

The next set of accusations involves geneticist James Neel, who joined Chagnon in the fieldwork of the Yanomamo in He accuses Neel of helping the measles epidemic worsen because he provided outdated vaccines and misadvised the Yanomamo, which resulted in the deaths of thousands.

Subsequently, the American Anthropological Association AAA was compelled to launch an investigation on the controversy.

Helpful Sites

It is undisputed that this controversy is repelling. Even if all of the accusations were false, the mere accusations show that ethical standards were broken. Surprisingly, the controversy does reap some positive consequences; it encourages personnel—within and outside the field—to consider the appropriate standards that anthropologist should be held to.

Ethical questions arise, such as: The unbalance of power between the anthropologist from developed societies and their isolated subjects is a relationship that needs to be treated with delicacy to avoid exploitation.

We can compare the relationship that researcher and filmmaker John Marshall had with the Juhoansi people of the Kalahari Desert for ethical analysis.

Access denied | pfmlures.com used Cloudflare to restrict access

John Marshall first went to the Kalahari in and researched the Juhoansi for fifty years thereafter.In the film Yanomami: The Dying Tribe, how was the Yanomami’s mode of production changing, and why?

The Yanomami are classified as horticulturalists, using natural resources from the rainforest in . My name is Eric Dunning and this is my proposal to go and study the Yanomamo tribe in the rain forests of Brazil.

I have compiled a historical outline of the Yanomamo tribe and some of their religion and culture, ranging from marital status to the type of food they eat.

The controversy revolving the tribe of the Yanomamo and the professionals linked to anthropology has caught the world’s attention.

Rapid and unforeseeable events have set the tone for the controversy. The Yanomami are an indigenous tribe also called Yanomamo, Yanomam, and Sanuma who live in the tropical rain forest of Southern Venezuela and Northern Brazil.

The society is composed of four subdivisions of Indians. Yanomamo: People of the Rainforest Essay - Yanomamo: People of the Rainforest Located in the Amazon Basin of Southern Venezuela and Northern Brazil, the Yanomamo are an indigenous group numbering close to 23, - The Yanomamo My name is Eric Dunning and this is my proposal to go and study the Yanomamo tribe in the rain forests of Brazil.

I have compiled a historical outline of the Yanomamo tribe and some of their religion and culture, ranging from marital status to the type of food they eat.

Yanomamo tribe essay
The Yanomamo Culture Essay Example | Graduateway